PCA History

Issue · part of Courts and review

Judicial cases

Complaints and cases before presbyteries and the SJC.

Includes: Original jurisdiction and higher-court review of presbyteries Revoice and the TE Greg Johnson case

Submit a correction

Drag to pan. Ctrl or ⌘ + scroll, or pinch, to zoom. Select an event to see its responses.

Events

  1. 10th General Assembly orders Gulf Coast Presbytery to re-examine a licentiate rejected over theonomy draft

    PCA General Assembly · Grand Rapids, MI

  2. 11th General Assembly annuls North Georgia Presbytery's exam of a licentiate who denied the Christian Sabbath draft

    PCA General Assembly · Norfolk, VA

  3. 11th General Assembly annuls an ordination exam in part over the candidate's view on women deacons draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Norfolk, VA

  4. Grace Presbytery asks for a plan to adjudicate General Assembly cases between Assemblies draft

    Grace Presbytery

  5. 12th General Assembly finds Ascension Presbytery did not carry out the Case 2 directives draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Baton Rouge, LA

  6. 12th General Assembly denies a complaint against an ordination with a Sabbath exception (Case 1) draft

    PCA General Assembly · Baton Rouge, LA

  7. Presbyteries reject amendments that would forbid a higher court to "act for" a lower court draft

    Presbyterian Church in America

  8. 15th General Assembly ends the complaint over a teaching elder's ordination exceptions (Bogue et al. vs. Ascension) draft

    PCA General Assembly · Grand Rapids, MI

  9. 16th General Assembly upholds Western Carolina Presbytery's suspension, not deposition, of a teaching elder who confessed homosexual sin draft

    PCA General Assembly · Knoxville, TN

  10. 17th General Assembly denies a complaint over church games on the Lord's Day (Stine vs. Southern Florida) draft

    PCA General Assembly · La Mirada, CA

  11. 19th General Assembly approves the SJC judgment on a Sunday school teacher who held theistic evolution (Case 90-3) draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Birmingham, AL

  12. Standing Judicial Commission upholds a session that declined elder candidates over theonomy draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  13. 20th General Assembly sends down an amendment to let a neighboring presbytery try a minister's case draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Roanoke, VA

  14. Presbyteries defeat the BCO 34-1 amendment on assigning cases to a neighboring presbytery draft

    Presbyterian Church in America

  15. 22nd General Assembly approves the SJC judgment that lets stand a licensure despite the candidate's views on creation and the flood (Case 92-9a) draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Atlanta, GA

  16. 25th General Assembly approves the SJC judgment in a complaint over a theonomist's transfer exam in Southern Florida Presbytery draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Colorado Springs, CO

  17. 26th General Assembly adopts the SJC majority report in Mt. Carmel Session v. New Jersey Presbytery on creation days draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC), Presbytery of New Jersey · St. Louis, MO

  18. SJC denies two complaints over James River Presbytery's actions on a minister's view of the creation days (Cases 98-1 and 98-5) draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  19. Tennessee Valley Presbytery finds the Cedar Springs session in conformity and declares women should not preach draft

    Tennessee Valley Presbytery

  20. Louisiana Presbytery overtures the 28th General Assembly to discipline Tennessee Valley Presbytery draft

    Louisiana Presbytery

  21. South Coast Presbytery memorializes the 28th General Assembly against Central Florida Presbytery's reception of a minister under charges draft

    South Coast Presbytery

  22. 28th General Assembly assumes original jurisdiction in the John Wood matter and refers it to the Standing Judicial Commission draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Tampa, FL

  23. Standing Judicial Commission finds no strong presumption of guilt against TE John Wood draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  24. Evangel Presbytery overtures the 29th General Assembly to set procedures for original jurisdiction under BCO 33-1 and BCO 34-1 draft

    Evangel Presbytery

  25. Ascension Presbytery overtures the 29th General Assembly to have the CCB review the SJC's handling of the John Wood matter draft

    Presbytery of the Ascension

  26. Western Carolina Presbytery overtures the 29th General Assembly to remove the concurring opinions in the John Wood matter draft

    Western Carolina Presbytery

  27. 29th General Assembly assigns requests to assume original jurisdiction to the Standing Judicial Commission draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Dallas, TX

  28. 29th General Assembly declines to remove the John Wood concurring opinion but asks the SJC for procedures on temperate language draft

    PCA General Assembly · Dallas, TX

  29. 29th General Assembly answers Ascension Presbytery's overture on the SJC's John Wood procedure in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly · Dallas, TX

  30. 29th General Assembly answers Evangel Presbytery's original-jurisdiction overtures in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly · Dallas, TX

  31. 29th General Assembly declines to condemn the Standing Judicial Commission's handling of the John Wood matter draft

    PCA General Assembly, Calvary Presbytery, Western Carolina Presbytery · Dallas, TX

  32. Presbyteries reject the BCO 34-1 amendment requiring ten percent of presbyteries for original jurisdiction draft

    Presbyterian Church in America

  33. Ohio Valley Presbytery and nineteen other presbyteries overture the 30th General Assembly to require ten percent of presbyteries for original jurisdiction draft

    Ohio Valley Presbytery

  34. Potomac Presbytery overtures the 30th General Assembly to require greater consensus to assume original jurisdiction draft

    Potomac Presbytery

  35. 30th General Assembly sends down an amendment to BCO 34-1 requiring ten percent of presbyteries for original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly · Birmingham, AL

  36. 31st General Assembly states that the 30th General Assembly's women-in-the-military action compels no discipline draft

    PCA General Assembly, Potomac Presbytery, Chesapeake Presbytery · Charlotte, NC

  37. Central Carolina Presbytery memorializes the Standing Judicial Commission about TE Steve Wilkins draft

    Central Carolina Presbytery

  38. Suncoast Florida Presbytery asks the Assembly to declare the Auburn Avenue session heterodox draft

    Suncoast Florida Presbytery

  39. Standing Judicial Commission finds the Suncoast Florida overture on Auburn Avenue out of accord with the Book of Church Order draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  40. Standing Judicial Commission directs Louisiana Presbytery to examine TE Steve Wilkins draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  41. Louisiana Presbytery examines TE Steve Wilkins and finds no strong presumption of guilt draft

    Louisiana Presbytery

  42. Crossroads Community Church complains against Hsu's licensure draft

    Crossroads Community Church (CCC)

  43. Standing Judicial Commission cites Louisiana Presbytery for trial over TE Steve Wilkins draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  44. Standing Judicial Commission sustains a complaint against Louisiana Presbytery's handling of TE Steve Wilkins draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  45. Louisiana Presbytery pleads guilty to one specification in its trial before the Standing Judicial Commission draft

    Louisiana Presbytery

  46. Philadelphia Presbytery answers the Crossroads complaint in the negative draft

    Philadelphia Presbytery

  47. Crossroads takes its complaint about Hsu's licensure to the General Assembly draft

    Crossroads Community Church (CCC)

  48. Standing Judicial Commission tries Louisiana Presbytery and imposes the censure of admonition draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  49. Moderator of the 36th General Assembly reads the admonition to Louisiana Presbytery draft

    PCA General Assembly, Louisiana Presbytery · Dallas, TX

  50. Standing Judicial Commission denies the complaints about Hsu's licensure and ordination draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  51. 37th General Assembly rewrites the Standing Judicial Commission's memorial procedure draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Orlando, FL

  52. 37th General Assembly rules the Crossroads overture out of order draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Orlando, FL

  53. 37th General Assembly declines Central Carolina's amendment on original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Central Carolina Presbytery · Orlando, FL

  54. Siouxlands Presbytery rejects its committee's finding against TE Greg Lawrence draft

    Presbytery of the Siouxlands

  55. Standing Judicial Commission orders Siouxlands Presbytery to investigate TE Greg Lawrence draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  56. Standing Judicial Commission sustains a complaint about Pacific Northwest Presbytery's handling of TE Peter Leithart draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  57. Standing Judicial Commission upholds Rocky Mountain Presbytery on a candidate's view of women teaching draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  58. Standing Judicial Commission denies a complaint about Siouxlands Presbytery's handling of TE Joshua Moon draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  59. Siouxlands Presbytery finds a strong presumption of guilt against TE Greg Lawrence draft

    Presbytery of the Siouxlands

  60. Missouri Presbytery finds no strong presumption of guilt in the teaching of TE Jeffrey Meyers draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  61. Philadelphia Presbytery rules the complaint about Hsu's call out of order draft

    Philadelphia Presbytery

  62. Siouxlands Presbytery finds TE Greg Lawrence not guilty draft

    Presbytery of the Siouxlands

  63. Pacific Northwest Presbytery tries TE Peter Leithart and finds him not guilty draft

    Pacific Northwest Presbytery

  64. Missouri Presbytery tries TE Jeffrey Meyers draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  65. Standing Judicial Commission finds Missouri Presbytery erred on TE Jeffrey Meyers but rules the complaint moot draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  66. Standing Judicial Commission rules the complaint against the Meyers verdict out of order draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  67. Standing Judicial Commission denies the complaint against TE Peter Leithart's acquittal draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  68. Three presbyteries ask the Assembly to assume original jurisdiction over TE Peter Leithart draft

    Gulf Coast Presbytery, Calvary Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery

  69. Standing Judicial Commission finds Philadelphia Presbytery in error for ruling the City Line complaint out of order draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  70. 41st General Assembly rules out of order the records minority reports on the Leithart and Meyers trials draft

    PCA General Assembly, Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR) · Greenville, SC

  71. 41st General Assembly sends down a rule on references and declines a lower threshold for original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Pacific Northwest Presbytery · Greenville, SC

  72. 41st General Assembly rules out of order the overtures to rehear the Leithart and Meyers cases draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Greenville, SC

  73. Standing Judicial Commission answers the original jurisdiction overtures on TE Peter Leithart in the negative draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  74. Standing Judicial Commission orders a new trial of TE Greg Lawrence draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  75. 42nd General Assembly enacts the amendment to Book of Church Order 43-10 on references after a non-indictment draft

    PCA General Assembly · Houston, TX

  76. Siouxlands Presbytery retries TE Greg Lawrence and finds him not guilty draft

    Presbytery of the Siouxlands

  77. Standing Judicial Commission denies the complaint against TE Greg Lawrence's second acquittal draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  78. Covenant Seminary tells the 46th General Assembly it is not hosting or sponsoring Revoice draft

    Covenant Theological Seminary · Atlanta, GA

  79. Revoice holds its first conference at Memorial Presbyterian Church in St. Louis draft

    Revoice · St. Louis, MO

  80. TE Greg Johnson and the Memorial session ask Missouri Presbytery to investigate them draft

    Greg Johnson, Memorial Presbyterian Church (St. Louis, MO) · St. Louis, MO

  81. Missouri Presbytery forms a committee to investigate Memorial and TE Greg Johnson draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  82. Other presbyteries write to Missouri Presbytery about Revoice and TE Greg Johnson draft

    Calvary Presbytery, Southwest Florida Presbytery, Savannah River Presbytery, Westminster Presbytery, Southeast Alabama Presbytery

  83. Missouri Presbytery adopts its committee's report on Memorial and Revoice draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  84. Missouri Presbytery asks for a committee to seek consensus on sexuality draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  85. 47th General Assembly declines to define "credible report" in BCO 40-5 draft

    PCA General Assembly, Savannah River Presbytery · Dallas, TX

  86. Missouri Presbytery partly sustains a complaint and opens an investigation of TE Greg Johnson draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  87. Missouri Presbytery amends its theological judgments on Revoice draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  88. Central Georgia Presbytery asks the General Assembly to assume original jurisdiction over the Missouri case draft

    Central Georgia Presbytery

  89. Savannah River Presbytery joins the request for original jurisdiction over the Missouri case draft

    Savannah River Presbytery

  90. Missouri Presbytery adopts 49 affirmations and denials on sexuality draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  91. Missouri Presbytery finds no strong presumption of guilt against TE Greg Johnson draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  92. Southeast Alabama Presbytery joins the request for original jurisdiction over TE Greg Johnson draft

    Southeast Alabama Presbytery

  93. Tennessee Valley Presbytery overtures to shield abuse accusers from face-to-face contact with the accused in church trials draft

    Tennessee Valley Presbytery

  94. Standing Judicial Commission denies TE Ryan Speck's complaint against Missouri Presbytery (Case 2020-12) draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  95. Standing Judicial Commission answers the 2020 requests for original jurisdiction over the Missouri case draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  96. Standing Judicial Commission sustains in part TE Ryan Speck's complaint over the Revoice judgments (Case 2020-05) draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  97. Southeast Alabama and Grace presbyteries again ask for original jurisdiction over TE Greg Johnson draft

    Southeast Alabama Presbytery, Grace Presbytery

  98. Presbyteries reject the ten-percent threshold for original jurisdiction requests draft

    Presbyterian Church in America

  99. 49th General Assembly sends down BCO 35 victim protection amendments draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Birmingham, AL

  100. 49th General Assembly sends down a ten-percent threshold for original jurisdiction requests draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee, Houston Metro Presbytery · Birmingham, AL

  101. Memorial Presbyterian Church votes to leave the PCA draft

    Memorial Presbyterian Church (St. Louis, MO) · St. Louis, MO

  102. Missouri Presbytery removes TE Greg Johnson from its rolls and drops its new investigation draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  103. Standing Judicial Commission rules it has no jurisdiction over TE Greg Johnson after his departure (Case 2022-12) draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  104. 50th General Assembly enacts BCO 35 victim protection amendments draft

    PCA General Assembly · Memphis, TN

  105. 50th General Assembly declines to let all persons be witnesses in church trials draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee, Northern California Presbytery · Memphis, TN

  106. SJC denies a complaint that Tennessee Valley Presbytery should have cited a session for a youth Super Bowl party (Case 2023-04) draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  107. Rio Grande Presbytery receives two letters asking it to investigate Garris draft

    Rio Grande Presbytery

  108. Rio Grande committee reports a "strong presumption of guilt" against Garris draft

    Rio Grande Presbytery

  109. Rio Grande Presbytery indicts Garris on two charges draft

    Rio Grande Presbytery

  110. Providence session asks Pittsburgh Presbytery to examine TE Rick Appleton draft

    Providence Presbyterian Church (Robinson Township) · Robinson Township, PA

  111. Rio Grande Presbytery convicts Garris on one charge and suspends him draft

    Rio Grande Presbytery

  112. Sean McGowan calls the Garris verdict "a travesty of justice" draft

    Sean McGowan

  113. Pittsburgh Presbytery indicts Appleton on two charges draft

    Pittsburgh Presbytery

  114. 53rd General Assembly declines an amendment to BCO 40-5 on citing a lower court draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee, Potomac Presbytery · Louisville, KY

  115. 53rd General Assembly sends down an amendment to BCO 34-1 on the Assembly assuming original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee, Westminster Presbytery · Louisville, KY

  116. Pittsburgh Presbytery convicts and deposes Appleton draft

    Pittsburgh Presbytery

  117. Jon Harris calls the Appleton charges "cheap shots" draft

    Jon Harris