PCA History

27th General Assembly · draft

SJC denies two complaints over James River Presbytery's actions on a minister's view of the creation days (Cases 98-1 and 98-5)

James River Presbytery sustained the ordination exam of a candidate who held that the six days of Genesis are “God’s work days” and not necessarily 24-hour days. It later granted him an exception and instructed him not to teach or preach that view. In Case 98-1 the Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) denied a complaint against the exam, 15-6. In Case 98-5 it denied a complaint against the instruction not to teach, 13-8. Dissenting opinions were filed in both cases, and the decisions were reported to the 27th General Assembly.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
James River Presbytery
Issues
Creation Judicial cases Stated differences in ordination exams

Sources

  • “the candidate considers the six days in Genesis as "God's work days" ("anthropomorphic") and not necessarily twenty-four hour days”
    M27GA, p. 70 · original verified
  • “the Presbytery acted within its constitutional authority to sustain the examination”
    M27GA, p. 71 · original verified
  • “Approved the decision: 15 Concurring, 6 Dissenting, 1 Recused, 2 Absent.”
    M27GA, p. 71 · original verified
  • “it further erodes the clear biblical and confessional teaching on creation and Genesis 1-2”
    M27GA, p. 72 · original verified
  • “Did James River Presbytery err when it instructed TE Andrew Conrad not to teach or preach his views on creation and "anthropomorphic days?"”
    M27GA, p. 74 · original verified
  • “Approved the decision: 13 Concurring, 8 Dissenting, 1 Recused, 2 Absent.”
    M27GA, p. 75 · original verified

Submit a correction

Responds to

  1. 26th General Assembly adopts the SJC majority report in Mt. Carmel Session v. New Jersey Presbytery on creation days draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC), Presbytery of New Jersey · St. Louis, MO

Related

  1. 26th General Assembly erects a study committee on the creation days draft

    PCA General Assembly, Central Carolina Presbytery, Westminster Presbytery · St. Louis, MO

  2. 25th General Assembly strikes presbytery-records exceptions on views of Genesis 1 draft

    PCA General Assembly, Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR), James River Presbytery, Presbytery of New Jersey · Colorado Springs, CO