PCA History

Issue

Doctrine and subscription

Events on doctrinal controversies and confessional subscription: the Federal Vision, the New Perspective on Paul, and stated differences in ordination exams.

Includes: Creation Federal Vision New Perspective on Paul Stated differences in ordination exams The Sabbath

Submit a correction

Drag to pan. Ctrl or ⌘ + scroll, or pinch, to zoom. Select an event to see its responses.

Events

  1. 4th General Assembly adopts Calvary Presbytery's overture on Sabbath observance draft

    PCA General Assembly, Calvary Presbytery · Greenville, SC

  2. 9th General Assembly opposes a bill to move national elections to Sunday draft

    PCA General Assembly · Fort Lauderdale, FL

  3. 10th General Assembly commends the Confessional Subscription paper and asks for written scruples draft

    PCA General Assembly · Grand Rapids, MI

  4. Grace Presbytery asks that licentiates file a written statement of subscription and scruples draft

    Grace Presbytery

  5. St. Louis Presbytery asks the Assembly to share its paper on system subscription draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  6. 11th General Assembly divides on written exceptions and sends the issue back to committee draft

    PCA General Assembly · Norfolk, VA

  7. 11th General Assembly annuls North Georgia Presbytery's exam of a licentiate who denied the Christian Sabbath draft

    PCA General Assembly · Norfolk, VA

  8. 11th General Assembly annuls an ordination exam in part over the candidate's view on women deacons draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Norfolk, VA

  9. St. Louis Presbytery asks for Assembly debate on subscription after the Ascension case draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  10. Missouri Presbytery overtures that ministers enter their differences with the Standards when they subscribe draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  11. 12th General Assembly says a view favoring women deacons is not by itself a bar to ordination draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Baton Rouge, LA

  12. 12th General Assembly answers the written-scruples overture in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly · Baton Rouge, LA

  13. 12th General Assembly finds Ascension Presbytery did not carry out the Case 2 directives draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Baton Rouge, LA

  14. 12th General Assembly denies a complaint against an ordination with a Sabbath exception (Case 1) draft

    PCA General Assembly · Baton Rouge, LA

  15. Tennessee Valley Presbytery asks that no man be refused ordination for objections to the Book of Church Order alone draft

    Tennessee Valley Presbytery

  16. Missouri Presbytery overtures the 13th General Assembly on exceptions to the Book of Church Order draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  17. 13th General Assembly adopts a statement on exceptions to the Book of Church Order draft

    PCA General Assembly · St. Louis, MO

  18. 13th General Assembly asks for unified language to record scruples to the Standards draft

    PCA General Assembly · St. Louis, MO

  19. 13th General Assembly denies Tennessee Valley's overture on objections to the Book of Church Order draft

    PCA General Assembly · St. Louis, MO

  20. 15th General Assembly ends the complaint over a teaching elder's ordination exceptions (Bogue et al. vs. Ascension) draft

    PCA General Assembly · Grand Rapids, MI

  21. 17th General Assembly denies a complaint over church games on the Lord's Day (Stine vs. Southern Florida) draft

    PCA General Assembly · La Mirada, CA

  22. 19th General Assembly approves the SJC judgment on a Sunday school teacher who held theistic evolution (Case 90-3) draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Birmingham, AL

  23. Westminster Presbytery sends the "Memorial from Concerned Presbyterians" to the 21st General Assembly draft

    Westminster Presbytery

  24. Commissioners protest the CoMission agreement and say the PCA was founded as a strict subscription church draft

    Morton H. Smith · Columbia, SC

  25. 21st General Assembly adopts Eastern Canada Presbytery's overture on MNA's promotion of Super Bowl parties draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of Eastern Canada · Columbia, SC

  26. 21st General Assembly answers the "Memorial from Concerned Presbyterians" draft

    PCA General Assembly · Columbia, SC

  27. Commissioners answer the CoMission protest on strict subscription draft

    PCA General Assembly · Columbia, SC

  28. 22nd General Assembly declines to declare strict subscription and suggests a Preface section on subscription draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Atlanta, GA

  29. 22nd General Assembly approves the SJC judgment that lets stand a licensure despite the candidate's views on creation and the flood (Case 92-9a) draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Atlanta, GA

  30. Eastern Canada Presbytery asks that no court add doctrinal requirements for office draft

    Presbytery of Eastern Canada

  31. Western Carolina Presbytery asks for a study committee on theological diversity in the PCA draft

    Western Carolina Presbytery

  32. 23rd General Assembly declines to limit doctrinal requirements for office by a new BCO 7-4 draft

    PCA General Assembly · Dallas, TX

  33. 23rd General Assembly declines a study committee on theological diversity draft

    PCA General Assembly · Dallas, TX

  34. 23rd General Assembly accepts New River Presbytery's response on a minister's exceptions on creation and deacons draft

    PCA General Assembly, Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR) · Dallas, TX

  35. 25th General Assembly strikes presbytery-records exceptions on views of Genesis 1 draft

    PCA General Assembly, Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR), James River Presbytery, Presbytery of New Jersey · Colorado Springs, CO

  36. North Georgia Presbytery overtures on when officers may teach their exceptions draft

    North Georgia Presbytery

  37. Central Carolina Presbytery overtures for a study committee on Genesis 1-3 and allowable exceptions draft

    Central Carolina Presbytery, Westminster Presbytery

  38. 26th General Assembly adopts the SJC majority report in Mt. Carmel Session v. New Jersey Presbytery on creation days draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC), Presbytery of New Jersey · St. Louis, MO

  39. 26th General Assembly erects a study committee on the creation days draft

    PCA General Assembly, Central Carolina Presbytery, Westminster Presbytery · St. Louis, MO

  40. SJC denies two complaints over James River Presbytery's actions on a minister's view of the creation days (Cases 98-1 and 98-5) draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  41. 27th General Assembly adopts a declaration on creation and the direct creation of Adam and Eve draft

    PCA General Assembly · Louisville, KY

  42. 27th General Assembly answers North Georgia's overture on teaching exceptions in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly, North Georgia Presbytery · Louisville, KY

  43. 28th General Assembly receives the creation study report and affirms that its diversity of views is acceptable draft

    PCA General Assembly · Tampa, FL

  44. 28th General Assembly answers an overture that exceptions may not be taught in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly, North Georgia Presbytery · Tampa, FL

  45. New River Presbytery overtures that no officer be refused ordination for a creation-days exception alone draft

    New River Presbytery

  46. Calvary Presbytery overtures that candidates who differ on the creation days request an exception draft

    Calvary Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery

  47. North Georgia Presbytery overtures to declare liberty of opinion on the Westminster divines' intent on creation draft

    North Georgia Presbytery

  48. 29th General Assembly answers the creation-days exception overtures in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly, Calvary Presbytery, New River Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery, North Georgia Presbytery · Dallas, TX

  49. Auburn Avenue Presbyterian Church holds its 2002 pastors' conference, where TE Steve Wilkins speaks on baptism and the covenant draft

    Auburn Avenue Presbyterian Church (Monroe, LA), Steve Wilkins · Monroe, LA

  50. Ohio Valley Presbytery overtures to amend BCO 21-4 for good-faith subscription draft

    Ohio Valley Presbytery

  51. 30th General Assembly sends down a BCO 21-4 amendment for good-faith subscription draft

    PCA General Assembly, Ohio Valley Presbytery · Birmingham, AL

  52. Illiana and three other presbyteries overture that presbytery minutes record approved exceptions draft

    Illiana Presbytery, Blue Ridge Presbytery, North Florida Presbytery

  53. 31st General Assembly enacts the good-faith subscription amendment to BCO 21-4 draft

    PCA General Assembly · Charlotte, NC

  54. 31st General Assembly amends the RAO so that presbytery minutes record approved exceptions draft

    PCA General Assembly, Illiana Presbytery, Presbytery of New Jersey, Westminster Presbytery · Charlotte, NC

  55. 31st General Assembly declines to erect an ad interim committee on subscription draft

    PCA General Assembly, Western Carolina Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery · Charlotte, NC

  56. Steve Wilkins and Duane Garner publish The Federal Vision draft

    Steve Wilkins · Monroe, LA

  57. 32nd General Assembly answers Grace Presbytery's overture on doctrinal subscription in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly, Grace Presbytery · Pittsburgh, PA

  58. 33rd General Assembly declines to distribute Mississippi Valley Presbytery's report on the New Perspective and Federal Vision draft

    PCA General Assembly · Chattanooga, TN

  59. 33rd General Assembly answers Ascension Presbytery's overture on preaching allowed differences in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Chattanooga, TN

  60. Louisiana Presbytery declares TE Steve Wilkins faithful to the Standards draft

    Louisiana Presbytery

  61. Missouri Presbytery adopts its study report on Federal Vision theology draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  62. Central Carolina Presbytery memorializes the Standing Judicial Commission about TE Steve Wilkins draft

    Central Carolina Presbytery

  63. Suncoast Florida Presbytery asks the Assembly to declare the Auburn Avenue session heterodox draft

    Suncoast Florida Presbytery

  64. Standing Judicial Commission finds the Suncoast Florida overture on Auburn Avenue out of accord with the Book of Church Order draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  65. 34th General Assembly amends RAO 14-3.e.5 on how presbytery minutes record stated differences draft

    PCA General Assembly, Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR) · Atlanta, GA

  66. 34th General Assembly answers Ascension Presbytery's overture on teaching exceptions in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Atlanta, GA

  67. 34th General Assembly erects an ad interim committee on Federal Vision, the New Perspective and Auburn Avenue theology draft

    PCA General Assembly, Rocky Mountain Presbytery · Atlanta, GA

  68. Standing Judicial Commission directs Louisiana Presbytery to examine TE Steve Wilkins draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  69. Potomac Presbytery overtures the 35th General Assembly on teaching approved exceptions draft

    Potomac Presbytery

  70. Louisiana Presbytery examines TE Steve Wilkins and finds no strong presumption of guilt draft

    Louisiana Presbytery

  71. Siouxlands Presbytery adopts affirmations and denials on the New Perspective and Federal Vision draft

    Presbytery of the Siouxlands

  72. Federal Vision study committee reports nine declarations to the 35th General Assembly draft

    Ad Interim Committee on Federal Vision, New Perspective, and Auburn Avenue Theologies, Paul Fowler, Sean Michael Lucas · Memphis, TN

  73. 35th General Assembly recommends the nine Federal Vision declarations as a faithful exposition of the Standards draft

    PCA General Assembly · Memphis, TN

  74. 35th General Assembly answers Potomac's overture on teaching exceptions in the negative without prejudice draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Memphis, TN

  75. Good Shepherd session protests the 35th General Assembly's Federal Vision action draft

    Good Shepherd Presbyterian Church (Minnetonka, MN)

  76. Philadelphia Presbytery approves Jason Hsu for licensure despite his view on women deacons draft

    Philadelphia Presbytery

  77. Crossroads Community Church complains against Hsu's licensure draft

    Crossroads Community Church (CCC)

  78. Standing Judicial Commission cites Louisiana Presbytery for trial over TE Steve Wilkins draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  79. Standing Judicial Commission sustains a complaint against Louisiana Presbytery's handling of TE Steve Wilkins draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  80. Louisiana Presbytery pleads guilty to one specification in its trial before the Standing Judicial Commission draft

    Louisiana Presbytery

  81. Philadelphia Presbytery answers the Crossroads complaint in the negative draft

    Philadelphia Presbytery

  82. Auburn Avenue Presbyterian Church and TE Steve Wilkins leave the PCA for the Confederation of Reformed Evangelical Churches draft

    Auburn Avenue Presbyterian Church (Monroe, LA), Steve Wilkins · Monroe, LA

  83. Crossroads takes its complaint about Hsu's licensure to the General Assembly draft

    Crossroads Community Church (CCC)

  84. Standing Judicial Commission tries Louisiana Presbytery and imposes the censure of admonition draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  85. Northern California Presbytery disagrees with the exception on commissioned deaconesses draft

    Northern California Presbytery

  86. Moderator of the 36th General Assembly reads the admonition to Louisiana Presbytery draft

    PCA General Assembly, Louisiana Presbytery · Dallas, TX

  87. Pacific Northwest Presbytery finds TE Peter Leithart's views not out of accord with the fundamentals draft

    Pacific Northwest Presbytery

  88. Ascension Presbytery overtures the 37th General Assembly to require ministers from other denominations to state their differences draft

    Presbytery of the Ascension

  89. Standing Judicial Commission denies the complaints about Hsu's licensure and ordination draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  90. 37th General Assembly declines Central Carolina's amendment on original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Central Carolina Presbytery · Orlando, FL

  91. 37th General Assembly sends down Ascension's amendment to BCO 13-6 on transferring ministers' differences draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Orlando, FL

  92. Siouxlands Presbytery rejects its committee's finding against TE Greg Lawrence draft

    Presbytery of the Siouxlands

  93. Standing Judicial Commission orders Siouxlands Presbytery to investigate TE Greg Lawrence draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  94. Standing Judicial Commission sustains a complaint about Pacific Northwest Presbytery's handling of TE Peter Leithart draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  95. Standing Judicial Commission upholds Rocky Mountain Presbytery on a candidate's view of women teaching draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  96. Standing Judicial Commission denies a complaint about Siouxlands Presbytery's handling of TE Joshua Moon draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  97. Siouxlands Presbytery finds a strong presumption of guilt against TE Greg Lawrence draft

    Presbytery of the Siouxlands

  98. Missouri Presbytery finds no strong presumption of guilt in the teaching of TE Jeffrey Meyers draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  99. Philadelphia Presbytery approves Hsu's call to City Line Church without questions on the diaconate draft

    Philadelphia Presbytery, City Line Church

  100. 39th General Assembly enacts the BCO 13-6 amendment on differences of ministers from other denominations draft

    PCA General Assembly · Virginia Beach, VA

  101. 39th General Assembly requires presbytery minutes to record ministers' stated differences in their own words draft

    PCA General Assembly, Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR), Committee on Constitutional Business (CCB) · Virginia Beach, VA

  102. 39th General Assembly cites Pacific Northwest Presbytery for approving a paedocommunion exception draft

    PCA General Assembly, Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR) · Virginia Beach, VA

  103. Siouxlands Presbytery finds TE Greg Lawrence not guilty draft

    Presbytery of the Siouxlands

  104. Pacific Northwest Presbytery tries TE Peter Leithart and finds him not guilty draft

    Pacific Northwest Presbytery

  105. Rocky Mountain Presbytery overtures the 40th General Assembly to reject all evolutionary views of Adam's origin draft

    Rocky Mountain Presbytery, Savannah River Presbytery

  106. Missouri Presbytery tries TE Jeffrey Meyers draft

    Missouri Presbytery

  107. Standing Judicial Commission finds Missouri Presbytery erred on TE Jeffrey Meyers but rules the complaint moot draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  108. 40th General Assembly requires the Committee on Theological Examination to report examinees' exceptions in their own words draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Louisville, KY

  109. 40th General Assembly declines an in thesi statement on Adam and points to the Standards draft

    PCA General Assembly, Potomac Presbytery · Louisville, KY

  110. 40th General Assembly sends down an amendment to BCO 19-2 on licentiates' stated differences draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Louisville, KY

  111. Standing Judicial Commission rules the complaint against the Meyers verdict out of order draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  112. Standing Judicial Commission denies the complaint against TE Peter Leithart's acquittal draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  113. Three presbyteries ask the Assembly to assume original jurisdiction over TE Peter Leithart draft

    Gulf Coast Presbytery, Calvary Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery

  114. 41st General Assembly enacts the BCO 19-2 amendment on licentiates' stated differences draft

    PCA General Assembly · Greenville, SC

  115. 41st General Assembly rules out of order the records minority reports on the Leithart and Meyers trials draft

    PCA General Assembly, Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR) · Greenville, SC

  116. 41st General Assembly declines North Texas Presbytery's request for a study committee on the Sabbath in the Standards draft

    PCA General Assembly, North Texas Presbytery · Greenville, SC

  117. 41st General Assembly sends down a rule on references and declines a lower threshold for original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Pacific Northwest Presbytery · Greenville, SC

  118. 41st General Assembly refers James River's overture on change of views back to the presbytery draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Greenville, SC

  119. 41st General Assembly rules out of order the overtures to rehear the Leithart and Meyers cases draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Greenville, SC

  120. Standing Judicial Commission answers the original jurisdiction overtures on TE Peter Leithart in the negative draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  121. Philadelphia Presbytery overtures the 42nd General Assembly for a study committee on the third ordination vow draft

    Philadelphia Presbytery

  122. Standing Judicial Commission orders a new trial of TE Greg Lawrence draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  123. 42nd General Assembly enacts the amendment to Book of Church Order 43-10 on references after a non-indictment draft

    PCA General Assembly · Houston, TX

  124. 42nd General Assembly answers Fellowship Presbytery's overture to warn against erroneous views of creation in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly, Fellowship Presbytery · Houston, TX

  125. 42nd General Assembly declines a study committee on the third ordination vow draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Houston, TX

  126. 43rd General Assembly declines committees to propose revisions to the Standards on the Sabbath draft

    PCA General Assembly, North Texas Presbytery, Tennessee Valley Presbytery · Chattanooga, TN

  127. 43rd General Assembly cites Philadelphia Presbytery for ordaining a man unsure of the prohibition of women elders draft

    PCA General Assembly, Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR) · Chattanooga, TN

  128. Siouxlands Presbytery retries TE Greg Lawrence and finds him not guilty draft

    Presbytery of the Siouxlands

  129. 44th General Assembly commends Covenant College for forfeiting a tennis championship scheduled on the Lord's Day draft

    PCA General Assembly, Calvary Presbytery · Mobile, AL

  130. Standing Judicial Commission denies the complaint against TE Greg Lawrence's second acquittal draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  131. SJC denies a complaint that Tennessee Valley Presbytery should have cited a session for a youth Super Bowl party (Case 2023-04) draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)

  132. 52nd General Assembly sends down an amendment requiring ruling elder and deacon nominees to state their differences with the Standards draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee, Nashville Presbytery · Chattanooga, TN