PCA History

37th General Assembly · · Orlando, FL draft

37th General Assembly declines Central Carolina's amendment on original jurisdiction

Central Carolina Presbytery asked the 37th General Assembly to amend BCO 34-1 so that five presbyteries could ask the Assembly to assume original jurisdiction over a minister, after his presbytery had rendered its judgment or had reasonable time to do so. Its rationale cited the Louisiana case, in which “the entire Presbytery was eventually put on trial” instead of the minister. The Assembly answered the overture in the negative. The Overtures Committee granted that the overture identified “a real problem,” but said the remedy would prolong cases and raise “the problem of double jeopardy.”

Actors
PCA General Assembly, Central Carolina Presbytery
Issues
Original jurisdiction and higher-court review of presbyteries Judicial cases Federal Vision

Sources

  • “Fourth Session - Thursday Morning June 18, 2009”
    M37GA, p. 213 · original verified
    M37GA, p. 213, with the quote highlighted
  • “Amend BCO 34-1 and 33-1 Regarding Assumption of Original Jurisdiction”) be answered in the negative.”
    M37GA, p. 262 · original verified
    M37GA, p. 262, with the quote highlighted
  • “the proposed solution would likely protract the matter interminably and raises the problem of “double jeopardy””
    M37GA, p. 262 · original verified
    M37GA, p. 262, with the quote highlighted
  • “the entire Presbytery was eventually put on trial in a novel and somewhat awkward proceeding (Case 2007-14, M36GA Dallas)”
    M37GA, p. 266 · original verified
    M37GA, p. 266, with the quote highlighted
  • “Assumption shall be postponed until the Presbytery has concluded its consideration of the matter and rendered its judgment”
    M37GA, p. 263 · original verified
    M37GA, p. 263, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Responds to

  1. Standing Judicial Commission tries Louisiana Presbytery and imposes the censure of admonition draft

    Standing Judicial Commission (SJC), J. Howard (Howie) Donahoe

Responses

  1. 41st General Assembly sends down a rule on references and declines a lower threshold for original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Pacific Northwest Presbytery · Greenville, SC

Related

  1. Three presbyteries ask the Assembly to assume original jurisdiction over TE Peter Leithart draft

    Gulf Coast Presbytery, Calvary Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery

  2. 41st General Assembly rules out of order the overtures to rehear the Leithart and Meyers cases draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Greenville, SC