PCA History

41st General Assembly · · Greenville, SC draft

41st General Assembly rules out of order the overtures to rehear the Leithart and Meyers cases

Illiana Presbytery’s Overture 19 asked the Assembly to have the Standing Judicial Commission rehear the Leithart case (2012-05). Great Lakes Presbytery’s Overture 23 asked it to direct the commission to hear the complaint about TE Jeffrey Meyers (2012-09). The Overtures Committee asked the Moderator to rule both out of order, because presbyteries “are not constitutionally permitted, in any way, to try to reopen SJC cases.” The Moderator so ruled, and the Assembly sustained him on appeal both times. The Stated Clerk, as parliamentarian, explained that the minority report on Overture 19 fell with the overture. Those minority reports said that the 2007 Assembly had “officially opposed the Federal Vision.”

Actors
PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee
About
Illiana Presbytery, Great Lakes Presbytery, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC), Peter Leithart, Jeffrey Meyers
Issues
Federal Vision Judicial cases Original jurisdiction and higher-court review of presbyteries

Sources

  • “Fifth Session – Thursday Afternoon June 20, 2013”
    M41GA, p. 36 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 36, with the quote highlighted
  • “Recommendation 19 was presented, requesting that the Moderator rule Overture 19 constitutionally out of order”
    M41GA, p. 40 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 40, with the quote highlighted
  • “Upon vote, the ruling of the chair on Overture 19 was sustained.”
    M41GA, p. 41 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 41, with the quote highlighted
  • “The ruling of the Moderator was appealed, and the chair was sustained.”
    M41GA, p. 41 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 41, with the quote highlighted
  • “Because a minority report is a subsidiary motion, that minority report goes away if the ruling of the chair on the point of order is sustained.”
    M41GA, p. 41 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 41, with the quote highlighted
  • “no review authority is given to Presbyteries and they are not constitutionally permitted, in any way, to try to reopen SJC cases”
    M41GA, p. 69 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 69, with the quote highlighted
  • “By adopting these recommendations the Assembly has officially opposed the Federal Vision, declaring it to be out of accord with our Standards”
    M41GA, p. 72 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 72, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Responds to

Related

  1. 41st General Assembly sends down a rule on references and declines a lower threshold for original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Pacific Northwest Presbytery · Greenville, SC

  2. Three presbyteries ask the Assembly to assume original jurisdiction over TE Peter Leithart draft

    Gulf Coast Presbytery, Calvary Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery

  3. 37th General Assembly declines Central Carolina's amendment on original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Central Carolina Presbytery · Orlando, FL