PCA History

41st General Assembly · · Greenville, SC draft

41st General Assembly sends down a rule on references and declines a lower threshold for original jurisdiction

Pacific Northwest Presbytery sent two overtures that drew on the Federal Vision cases. Overture 15 proposed that when a higher court rules that a lower court erred by not indicting, it must accept a reference of the case; the rationale cited Bordwine v. Pacific Northwest and Sawyers v. Missouri, where a presbytery could be made to try “a man … whom it does not believe should be put on trial.” The Assembly answered it in the affirmative and sent it to the presbyteries. Overture 16 would have let 5% of presbyteries ask for original jurisdiction when a presbytery “declines to order an indictment.” The 40th Assembly had referred the same text back in 2012, and the 41st answered it in the negative.

Actors
PCA General Assembly, Pacific Northwest Presbytery
Issues
Original jurisdiction and higher-court review of presbyteries Judicial cases Federal Vision

Sources

  • “Sixth Session – Thursday Evening June 20, 2013”
    M41GA, p. 50 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 50, with the quote highlighted
  • “Complaint Against a Non-indictment in a Doctrinal Case or Case of Public Scandal,” p. 847) be answered in the Affirmative.”
    M41GA, p. 68 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 68, with the quote highlighted
  • “See Cases 2009-06 Bordwine v. Pacific Northwest and 2011-06 Sawyers v. Missouri”
    M41GA, p. 848 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 848, with the quote highlighted
  • “a Presbytery might put a man on trial whom it does not believe should be put on trial”
    M41GA, p. 848 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 848, with the quote highlighted
  • “this overture resembles multiple previous unsuccessful attempts to change BCO 33-1 and 34-1 over the last twelve years”
    M41GA, p. 68 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 68, with the quote highlighted
  • “declines to order an indictment in doctrinal cases or cases of public scandal and two at least 5% of the other Presbyteries”
    M41GA, p. 849 · original verified
    M41GA, p. 849, with the quote highlighted
  • “be answered by referring the Overture without prejudice back to Pacific Northwest Presbytery”
    M40GA, p. 74 · original verified
    M40GA, p. 74, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Responds to

  1. 37th General Assembly declines Central Carolina's amendment on original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Central Carolina Presbytery · Orlando, FL

Related

  1. 41st General Assembly rules out of order the overtures to rehear the Leithart and Meyers cases draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Greenville, SC

  2. Three presbyteries ask the Assembly to assume original jurisdiction over TE Peter Leithart draft

    Gulf Coast Presbytery, Calvary Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery