PCA History

draft

Standing Judicial Commission sustains a complaint about Pacific Northwest Presbytery's handling of TE Peter Leithart

In Case 2009-6, Bordwine et al. v. Pacific Northwest Presbytery, the Standing Judicial Commission sustained the complaint 17-2. It held that without judicial process the presbytery could not declare TE Peter Leithart’s views either in or out of accord with the Standards. It found that his views on baptism, the bi-covenantal structure of Scripture and imputation “suggest a strong presumption of guilt.” The presbytery could counsel him to recant or to move to “some other branch of the visible church”; otherwise it was to act under Book of Church Order (BCO) 31-2 before its fall meeting. The minutes print no date for the decision; the commission met in October 2009, January 2010 and March 2010.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Pacific Northwest Presbytery, Peter Leithart
Issues
Federal Vision Judicial cases

Sources

  • “The Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) held a fall meeting October, 15 & 16, 2009, and a spring meeting March 4 & 5, 2010.”
    M38GA, p. 128 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 128, with the quote highlighted
  • “The Complaint is sustained, and the case is sent back to PNW with instructions”
    M38GA, p. 211 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 211, with the quote highlighted
  • “PNW erred by declaring that TE Leithart’s views were not out of accord with our standards.”
    M38GA, p. 212 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 212, with the quote highlighted
  • “suggest a strong presumption of guilt that these views represent offenses that could properly be the subject of judicial process”
    M38GA, p. 212 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 212, with the quote highlighted
  • “he is free to take timely steps toward affiliation with some other branch of the visible church that is consistent with his views”
    M38GA, p. 212 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 212, with the quote highlighted
  • “17 Concur, 2 Dissent, 3 Absent”
    M38GA, p. 213 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 213, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Responds to

Responses

  1. 41st General Assembly sends down a rule on references and declines a lower threshold for original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Pacific Northwest Presbytery · Greenville, SC

Related

  1. 37th General Assembly declines Central Carolina's amendment on original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Central Carolina Presbytery · Orlando, FL