PCA History

draft

Standing Judicial Commission denies a complaint about Siouxlands Presbytery's handling of TE Joshua Moon

TE Joshua Moon had led the September 2009 motions that cleared TE Greg Lawrence and had defended them in a paper. Foothills Community Church asked Siouxlands Presbytery to investigate him. In October 2009, after he denied the views alleged and answered questions, the presbytery found no strong presumption of guilt. In Case 2010-04, Sartorius et al. v. Siouxlands, the Standing Judicial Commission denied the complaint 19-1. It held that the presbytery had been diligent and that, without clear error, the commission “must defer” to its judgment of his credibility. The minutes print no date for the decision. The commission met on June 29 and October 21, 2010, and in the spring of 2011 (the report misprints “March 3, 2010”).

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Presbytery of the Siouxlands, Joshua Moon, Art Sartorius, Greg Lawrence
Issues
Federal Vision Judicial cases

Sources

  • “held a Called Meeting June 29, 2010, a Fall Meeting October, 21, 2010, and a Spring Meeting March 3, 2010”
    M39GA, p. 527 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 527, with the quote highlighted
  • “an Overture from the Foothills Community Church (FCC) asking Presbytery to investigate TE Moon”
    M39GA, p. 579 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 579, with the quote highlighted
  • “The Presbytery voted to find no strong presumption of guilt in TE Moon”
    M39GA, p. 579 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 579, with the quote highlighted
  • “One cannot properly impute implications that are drawn from a position to a person who expressly denies the implication.”
    M39GA, p. 582 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 582, with the quote highlighted
  • “this Court must defer to the Judgment of Presbytery”
    M39GA, p. 582 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 582, with the quote highlighted
  • “Adopted: 19 concurred, 1 dissent, 4 absent”
    M39GA, p. 583 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 583, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Responds to