PCA History

draft

Standing Judicial Commission tries Louisiana Presbytery and imposes the censure of admonition

In Case 2007-14, Presbyterian Church in America (PCA) v. Louisiana Presbytery, the Standing Judicial Commission tried the first specification on March 6, 2008, and dismissed it. On the second, to which the presbytery had pleaded guilty, it imposed the censure of admonition: Louisiana Presbytery was “derelict in its duty” when it failed to find a strong presumption of guilt about some of TE Steve Wilkins’ views. The vote was 16-1, with 2 disqualified and 5 absent. The minutes do not print the day of the vote; the commission met on March 6–7, 2008. In a concurring opinion RE Howard Donahoe wrote that the Book of Church Order (BCO) 34-1 phrase “refuses to act” is “poorly-worded” and set the bar for original jurisdiction too high.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Louisiana Presbytery, Steve Wilkins
Issues
Federal Vision Judicial cases Original jurisdiction and higher-court review of presbyteries

Sources

  • “October 18-19, 2007, February 1, 2008, and March 6-7, 2008”
    M36GA, p. 73 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 73, with the quote highlighted
  • “On March 6, 2008, the Standing Judicial Commission conducted the trial on Specification 1.”
    M36GA, p. 131 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 131, with the quote highlighted
  • “Specification 1 was dismissed by the Standing Judicial Commission”
    M36GA, p. 131 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 131, with the quote highlighted
  • “does hereby publicly admonish Louisiana Presbytery for its failure adequately to protect the peace, purity and unity of the Church”
    M36GA, p. 133 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 133, with the quote highlighted
  • “Louisiana Presbytery was derelict in its duty under BCO 13-9, 40-4, and 40-5”
    M36GA, p. 133 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 133, with the quote highlighted
  • “16 concur, 1 dissent, 2 disqualified, 5 absent.”
    M36GA, p. 135 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 135, with the quote highlighted
  • “The phrase “refuses to act” is poorly-worded.”
    M36GA, p. 135 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 135, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Responses

  1. Moderator of the 36th General Assembly reads the admonition to Louisiana Presbytery draft

    PCA General Assembly, Louisiana Presbytery · Dallas, TX

  2. 37th General Assembly declines Central Carolina's amendment on original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Central Carolina Presbytery · Orlando, FL