PCA History

draft

Standing Judicial Commission answers the original jurisdiction overtures on TE Peter Leithart in the negative

The 41st General Assembly referred Overtures 20, 21 and 22 to the Standing Judicial Commission, which answered them in the negative, 15-1 with one abstention. It held that Book of Church Order (BCO) 34-1 could not be used because Pacific Northwest Presbytery had not “refused to act”: it had indicted TE Peter Leithart, tried him, and dealt with the complaint. It added that the protection against double jeopardy barred a second trial on the same case, though new teaching could give new grounds. A failure to declare a mistrial after a completed trial was not a refusal to act. The response appears in the commission’s report to the 42nd General Assembly; the minutes print no date for the vote.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Gulf Coast Presbytery, Calvary Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery, Peter Leithart, Pacific Northwest Presbytery
Issues
Federal Vision Original jurisdiction and higher-court review of presbyteries Judicial cases

Sources

  • “a video conference stated meeting on October 17 – 18, 2013”
    M42GA, p. 499 · original verified
    M42GA, p. 499, with the quote highlighted
  • “(which Overtures are identical) be answered in the negative”
    M42GA, p. 581 · original verified
    M42GA, p. 581, with the quote highlighted
  • “BCO 34-1 cannot be invoked in this instance because Pacific Northwest Presbytery did not “refuse to act.””
    M42GA, p. 582 · original verified
    M42GA, p. 582, with the quote highlighted
  • “the fundamental principle of justice that protects against double jeopardy precludes further action in this case under BCO 34-1”
    M42GA, p. 582 · original verified
    M42GA, p. 582, with the quote highlighted
  • “The vote to adopt the Commission’s response to the Overtures in the Negative was 15 Concurring, 1 Abstaining, 1 Dissenting, 7 Absent.”
    M42GA, p. 583 · original verified
    M42GA, p. 583, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Responds to

  1. Three presbyteries ask the Assembly to assume original jurisdiction over TE Peter Leithart draft

    Gulf Coast Presbytery, Calvary Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery

Related

  1. 41st General Assembly rules out of order the overtures to rehear the Leithart and Meyers cases draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Greenville, SC

  2. 41st General Assembly sends down a rule on references and declines a lower threshold for original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Pacific Northwest Presbytery · Greenville, SC

  3. 37th General Assembly declines Central Carolina's amendment on original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Central Carolina Presbytery · Orlando, FL