PCA History

43rd General Assembly · · Chattanooga, TN draft

43rd General Assembly cites Philadelphia Presbytery for ordaining a man unsure of the prohibition of women elders

The Committee on Review of Presbytery Records voted 26-25 to cite Philadelphia Presbytery with an exception of substance. The presbytery, at a meeting on February 27, 2014, had ordained a man who was unsure that the New Testament “itself teaches a universal prohibition of women eldership”. A minority report asked the 43rd General Assembly to strike the exception, but the Assembly defeated it 258-554-42 and adopted the committee’s recommendation. In its response to the 44th General Assembly (2016), Philadelphia Presbytery agreed with the exception and said that in the future it “will not approve of a candidate who expresses doubts about the universal prohibition on women elders”.

Actors
PCA General Assembly, Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR)
About
Philadelphia Presbytery
Issues
Stated differences in ordination exams Women in the ministry of the church

Sources

  • “Presbytery ordained a man who is unsure that the New Testament “itself teaches a universal prohibition of women eldership””
    M43GA, p. 464 · original verified
  • “Vote to include this item as an exception of substance was 26-25-0”
    M43GA, p. 464 · original verified
  • “the substitute motion was defeated 258-554-42. Recommendation 56 was adopted.”
    M43GA, p. 32 · original verified
  • “in the future will not approve of a candidate who expresses doubts about the universal prohibition on women elders”
    M44GA, p. 433 · original verified

Submit a correction

Related

  1. 42nd General Assembly declines a study committee on the third ordination vow draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Houston, TX