PCA History

draft

Standing Judicial Commission upholds Rocky Mountain Presbytery on a candidate's view of women teaching

In January 2009 Rocky Mountain Presbytery sustained a candidate’s ordination exam. The candidate held that 1 Timothy 2:11-12 forbids a woman to preach but lets her teach Scripture to men and women under the session’s authority. In Case 2009-7, TE James Urish complained, and the Standing Judicial Commission ruled that the presbytery had not erred, with 20 judges concurring. Some members wrote that they had questions about the candidate’s exegesis, and a concurring opinion criticized it.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Rocky Mountain Presbytery
Issues
Women in the ministry of the church Judicial cases Stated differences in ordination exams

Sources

  • “Did Rocky Mountain Presbytery err in sustaining a candidate for ordination's theological examination when that candidate would in various ministries of the church, exclusive of preaching, allow a woman to teach from Scripture to men and women, all under the authority of the Session?”
    M38GA, p. 237 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 237, with the quote highlighted
  • “the candidate in this case expressly rejected the following – that a woman could serve as an elder; that a woman could preach in public worship”
    M38GA, p. 238 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 238, with the quote highlighted
  • “20 Concur, 1 Disqualified, 1 Absent”
    M38GA, p. 238 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 238, with the quote highlighted
  • “February 20, 2009, Complainants filed a Complaint”
    M38GA, p. 236 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 236, with the quote highlighted
  • “The Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) held a fall meeting October, 15 & 16, 2009, and a spring meeting March 4 & 5, 2010.”
    M38GA, p. 128 · original verified
    M38GA, p. 128, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction