PCA History

15th General Assembly · · Grand Rapids, MI draft

15th General Assembly ends the complaint over a teaching elder's ordination exceptions (Bogue et al. vs. Ascension)

From 1983 the General Assemblies heard complaints against Ascension Presbytery for sustaining the ordination exam of a teaching elder whose stated views differed from the Standards on five points. These included the invitation to the Lord’s Supper (Book of Church Order 58-4) and women deacons. In 1986 the 14th General Assembly first approved and then, on reconsideration, rejected its commission’s report by 158 to 204, and it elected a new commission. In 1987 the 15th General Assembly approved the new commission’s judgment. The commission said that the women-deacons point had become moot and that the teaching elder was “in acceptable compliance” with the Standards.

Actors
PCA General Assembly
About
Presbytery of the Ascension
Issues
Stated differences in ordination exams Judicial cases Women and the diaconate The Sabbath

Sources

  • “The Assembly then voted not to receive, approve, and accept the report of the Commission.”
    M14GA, p. 152 · original verified
  • “The Assembly voted to approve the full statement of the case and the judgment rendered”
    M15GA, p. 129 · original verified
  • “involved (1) invitation to the Lord's supper, (2) baptism and the visible church, (3) Sabbath observance, (4) the mode of baptism, and (5) women deacons”
    M15GA, p. 135 · original verified
  • “The 12th General Assembly adopted a statement indicating that a position such as that held by Mr. Lutjens as to women deacons should not in and of itself be deemed sufficient grounds for denial of ordination.”
    M15GA, p. 135 · original verified
  • “the majority of the commission is persuaded that Mr. Lutjens is in acceptable compliance with the standards of our church”
    M15GA, p. 135 · original verified

Submit a correction

Responds to

  1. 11th General Assembly annuls an ordination exam in part over the candidate's view on women deacons draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Norfolk, VA

  2. 12th General Assembly says a view favoring women deacons is not by itself a bar to ordination draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Baton Rouge, LA