PCA History

11th General Assembly · · Norfolk, VA draft

11th General Assembly annuls an ordination exam in part over the candidate's view on women deacons

The 11th General Assembly heard Case 2, a complaint by RE Val H. Barleman and others against Ascension Presbytery. The presbytery had sustained the ordination exam of a candidate who took several exceptions to the Standards. One specification was that he believed the office of deacon open to women, against Book of Church Order (BCO) 7-2 and 9-3, although he would comply with the BCO in practice. The judicial commission sustained that specification 9-2-0, and two others on the Lord’s Supper and baptism. It did not sustain the specifications on his exceptions on Sabbath observance and the mode of baptism. The Assembly adopted the judgment that annulled the presbytery’s action in sustaining the exam. A protest said that a view on women deacons held with compliance in practice did not contradict the ordination vows. A St. Louis Presbytery overture to the 12th General Assembly later said that 63 elders signed this protest.

Actors
PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension
Issues
Women and the diaconate Stated differences in ordination exams Judicial cases The Sabbath

Sources

  • “In violation of the BCO 7-2 and 9-3 the candidate believes the office of deacon is open to women as well as men.”
    M11GA, p. 140 · original verified
  • “at its September 11, 1982 meeting and declares the said action annulled”
    M11GA, p. 140 · original verified
  • “for a candidate to believe that Scriptures may be interpreted to allow the office of deacon to be open to women as well as men while his practice would be in accordance with the Form of Government's prohibition”
    M11GA, p. 141 · original verified
  • “as indicated by a protest signed by 63 at the General Assembly”
    M12GA, p. 57 · original verified
  • “voting 9-2-0 that the position that women deacons are scriptural is contrary to our BCO as it now stands”
    M11GA, p. 143 · original verified
  • “and questions 17 and 119 of the larger catechism.'Not Sustained 1-9-1”
    M11GA, p. 140 · original verified

Submit a correction

Responses

  1. 12th General Assembly says a view favoring women deacons is not by itself a bar to ordination draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Baton Rouge, LA

  2. 12th General Assembly finds Ascension Presbytery did not carry out the Case 2 directives draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Baton Rouge, LA