PCA History

51st General Assembly · draft

SJC denies a complaint that Tennessee Valley Presbytery should have cited a session for a youth Super Bowl party (Case 2023-04)

A Tennessee Valley Presbytery committee recommended an exception of substance against a session whose minutes noted a youth group Super Bowl party on a Sunday, under WLC 117-118 and WCF 21.8. The presbytery instead approved the minutes without exception and denied a complaint against that action. The Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) denied the complaint, 18-1, because the record gave no grounds for the presbytery’s action and so did not show error. A concurring opinion said that the decision did not address the underlying question of Sabbath observance. The decision is printed in the Minutes of the 51st General Assembly.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Tennessee Valley Presbytery
Issues
The Sabbath Judicial cases

Sources

  • “The youth group will have an outdoor Super Bowl Party on Feb. 7.”
    M51GA, p. 769 · original verified
  • “III. JUDGMENT 1. No.”
    M51GA, p. 770 · original verified
  • “The Record affords insufficient information to permit the higher court to find Presbytery to have erred in its interpretation of the Constitution”
    M51GA, p. 771 · original verified
  • “The SJC approved the Decision, as amended, on the following 18-1 vote”
    M51GA, p. 771 · original verified
  • “the SJC Decision should not be read as if it in any way addresses the underlying substantive issue”
    M51GA, p. 772 · original verified

Submit a correction