51st General Assembly · draft
SJC denies a complaint that Tennessee Valley Presbytery should have cited a session for a youth Super Bowl party (Case 2023-04)
A Tennessee Valley Presbytery committee recommended an exception of substance against a session whose minutes noted a youth group Super Bowl party on a Sunday, under WLC 117-118 and WCF 21.8. The presbytery instead approved the minutes without exception and denied a complaint against that action. The Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) denied the complaint, 18-1, because the record gave no grounds for the presbytery’s action and so did not show error. A concurring opinion said that the decision did not address the underlying question of Sabbath observance. The decision is printed in the Minutes of the 51st General Assembly.
- Actors
- Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
- About
- Tennessee Valley Presbytery
- Issues
- The Sabbath Judicial cases
Sources
-
“The youth group will have an outdoor Super Bowl Party on Feb. 7.”
M51GA, p. 769 · original verified -
“III. JUDGMENT 1. No.”
M51GA, p. 770 · original verified -
“The Record affords insufficient information to permit the higher court to find Presbytery to have erred in its interpretation of the Constitution”
M51GA, p. 771 · original verified -
“The SJC approved the Decision, as amended, on the following 18-1 vote”
M51GA, p. 771 · original verified -
“the SJC Decision should not be read as if it in any way addresses the underlying substantive issue”
M51GA, p. 772 · original verified
Related
-
17th General Assembly denies a complaint over church games on the Lord's Day (Stine vs. Southern Florida) draft
PCA General Assembly · La Mirada, CA
-
15th General Assembly ends the complaint over a teaching elder's ordination exceptions (Bogue et al. vs. Ascension) draft
PCA General Assembly · Grand Rapids, MI
-
12th General Assembly denies a complaint against an ordination with a Sabbath exception (Case 1) draft
PCA General Assembly · Baton Rouge, LA
-
11th General Assembly annuls an ordination exam in part over the candidate's view on women deacons draft
PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Norfolk, VA
-
11th General Assembly annuls North Georgia Presbytery's exam of a licentiate who denied the Christian Sabbath draft
PCA General Assembly · Norfolk, VA