PCA History

draft

Standing Judicial Commission sustains a complaint against Louisiana Presbytery's handling of TE Steve Wilkins

In Case 2007-8, TE James Jones et al. v. Louisiana Presbytery, the Standing Judicial Commission sustained the complaint 22-0, with one absent and one recused. It held that the presbytery had applied the wrong constitutional standard to TE Steve Wilkins’ differences with the Standards, and that the record supported a probable finding that it erred when it found no strong presumption of guilt. Because the case turned on interpretation of the Constitution, the commission said it owed the presbytery less deference (Book of Church Order 39-3). It annulled the presbytery’s denial of the complaint, and the memorial stayed before the commission.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Louisiana Presbytery, Steve Wilkins, James Jones
Issues
Federal Vision Judicial cases

Sources

  • “Does the record support a probable finding that Louisiana Presbytery erred, and thereby violated BCO 13-9.f, 40-4, and 40-5, when it failed to find a strong presumption of guilt”
    M36GA, p. 117 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 117, with the quote highlighted
  • “Therefore the complaint is sustained; Presbytery’s action of April 21, 2007, to deny the complaint of TE Jones is annulled”
    M36GA, p. 118 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 118, with the quote highlighted
  • “it failed to apply the proper Constitutional standard for dealing with TE Wilkins’ differences”
    M36GA, p. 118 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 118, with the quote highlighted
  • “a higher court should not consider itself obliged to exhibit the same deference to a lower court when the issues being reviewed involve the interpretation of the Constitution of the Church”
    M36GA, p. 118 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 118, with the quote highlighted
  • “RE Steven O’Ban and RE Tom Leopard, October 19, 2007”
    M36GA, p. 125 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 125, with the quote highlighted
  • “22– Concur; 1 -Absent; 1 –Recused”
    M36GA, p. 125 · original verified
    M36GA, p. 125, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Responses