PCA History

50th General Assembly · · Memphis, TN draft

50th General Assembly declines to let all persons be witnesses in church trials

Northern California Presbytery’s Overture 13 asked the 50th General Assembly to amend Book of Church Order (BCO) 35-1 and 35-7 so that persons who do not believe in God or a future state of rewards and punishments would no longer be barred as witnesses. It said that the Ad Interim Committee on Domestic Abuse and Sexual Assault had recommended the change, to allow testimony from persons such as medical professionals, especially in cases of abuse. The Overtures Committee recommended a negative answer. A minority report, presented by TE Timothy LeCroy, said the change mattered for the protection of children and victims of abuse; the motion to substitute it failed, 871-999-30. The Assembly answered Overture 13 in the negative, 1091-751-41, and answered Tennessee Valley’s Overture 2021-41 with reference to it.

Actors
PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee, Northern California Presbytery
Issues
Child protection and abuse Judicial cases

Sources

  • “Amend BCO 35-1 and 35-7 to Allow All Persons as Witnesses in Cases of Process”
    M50GA, p. 995 · original verified
  • “who “do not believe in the existence of God, or a future state of rewards and punishments;””
    M50GA, p. 995 · original verified
  • “recommended that this prohibition be modified to allow inclusion of medical professionals”
    M50GA, p. 995 · original verified
  • “The motion to make the substitute the main motion, answering Overture 13 in the affirmative as amended, failed. 871-999-30”
    M50GA, p. 85 · original verified
  • “The Overture Committee’s Recommendation 13, to answer Overture 13 in the negative was adopted. 1091-751-41”
    M50GA, p. 85 · original verified
  • “they are particularly crucial to ongoing endeavors to better protect children and victims of abuse”
    M50GA, p. 114 · original verified
  • “Overture 2021-41 be answered with reference to the Assembly’s answer to Overture 13. The Recommendation was adopted. 1277-180-120”
    M50GA, p. 92 · original verified

Submit a correction

Responds to

  1. 49th General Assembly sends down BCO 35 victim protection amendments draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee · Birmingham, AL

  2. 49th General Assembly receives the report on domestic abuse and sexual assault draft

    PCA General Assembly, Ad Interim Committee on Domestic Abuse and Sexual Assault · Birmingham, AL