draft
Presbyteries reject amendments that would forbid a higher court to "act for" a lower court
In 1987 the 15th General Assembly sent down amendments from its Ad Interim Committee to Study and Make Recommendations as to Structure and Procedure. One amendment to Book of Church Order (BCO) 40-5 said that a higher court may “act on” a case or “act against” a lower court, but may not “act for” it. A related amendment rewrote BCO 11-4. Commissioners led by TE Edmund Clowney protested that the amendments would impair the unity of the church in its government. In 1988 the 16th General Assembly reported that the presbyteries had rejected the BCO 40-5 and BCO 11-4 amendments, 14 for and 28 against.
- Actors
- Presbyterian Church in America
- Issues
- Original jurisdiction and higher-court review of presbyteries
Sources
-
“It may "act on" the issue or case properly before it relating to the lower court, or it may "act against" the lower court on the issue or case properly before it relating to the lower court, but it may not "act for" the lower court”
M15GA, p. 118 · original verified -
“adopting recommendations 4- 12 of the report of the Ad Interim Committee to Study and Make Recommendations as to Structure and Procedure”
M15GA, p. 121 · original verified -
“the proposed amendments restructure the polity of the Presbyterian Church in America so as to impair the expression of the unity of Christ's church in its government”
M15GA, p. 121 · original verified -
“This formulation takes up again a proposed amendment to BCO 11-4 approved in the 1984 General Assembly but rejected by the Presbyteries”
M15GA, p. 122 · original verified -
“Not approved by sufficient number of presbyteries”
M16GA, p. 102 · original verified -
“For 14 Against 28”
M16GA, p. 103 · original verified
Related
-
20th General Assembly sends down an amendment to let a neighboring presbytery try a minister's case draft
PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Roanoke, VA
-
Presbyteries defeat the BCO 34-1 amendment on assigning cases to a neighboring presbytery draft
Presbyterian Church in America
-
Louisiana Presbytery overtures the 28th General Assembly to discipline Tennessee Valley Presbytery draft
Louisiana Presbytery
-
28th General Assembly assumes original jurisdiction in the John Wood matter and refers it to the Standing Judicial Commission draft
PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Tampa, FL