PCA History

20th General Assembly · · Roanoke, VA draft

20th General Assembly sends down an amendment to let a neighboring presbytery try a minister's case

Ascension Presbytery overtured the 19th General Assembly to amend Book of Church Order (BCO) 34-1. If a presbytery refused to act in a doctrinal case or a case of public scandal, the Standing Judicial Commission, at the request of two other presbyteries, would assign the case to a neighboring presbytery. No such case would be tried de novo by a General Assembly commission. The overture said that the General Assembly’s judicial commission should be “a court of review and appeal and not a court of default” (BCO 40-5). The 19th General Assembly deferred it, and in 1992 the 20th General Assembly answered it in the affirmative and sent the amendment to the presbyteries.

Actors
PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension
Issues
Original jurisdiction and higher-court review of presbyteries

Sources

  • “Amend BCO 34-1 so Neighboring Presbytery May Adjudicate Case”
    M19GA, p. 165 · original verified
  • “Referred to CCB and deferred to the 20th GA”
    M19GA, p. 166 · original verified
  • “That General Assembly answer Overture #32 in the affirmative. Adopted”
    M20GA, p. 116 · original verified
  • “However, if the presbytery refuses to act in doctrinal cases or cases of public scandal the General Assembly, through its Standing Judicial Commission, at the request of two other presbyteries, shall assign the case to a neighboring presbytery for adjudication.”
    M20GA, p. 116 · original verified
  • “In no instance shall such cases be tried de novo by a judicial commission of General Assembly.”
    M20GA, p. 116 · original verified

Submit a correction

Responses