PCA History

draft

Standing Judicial Commission finds no strong presumption of guilt against TE John Wood

After a panel heard testimony at Cedar Springs on September 16, 2000, the Standing Judicial Commission found no strong presumption of guilt against TE John Wood, so judicial process was not instituted. It concluded that what the woman said at the August 1998 evening services “crossed the line,” but that the session had not intended her to preach and that this did not require process against Wood. It also found no clear evidence that his stated view, which excludes women from ordination and preaching but lets them do what unordained men may do, was outside the bounds of the Standards; the report went to the 29th General Assembly in June 2001.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Cedar Springs Presbyterian Church, John Wood
Issues
Women in the ministry of the church Judicial cases Original jurisdiction and higher-court review of presbyteries

Sources

  • “17 concur, 0 dissent, 0 abstain, 2 disqualified, 5 absent.”
    M29GA, p. 73 · original verified
    M29GA, p. 73, with the quote highlighted
  • “The investigation has not resulted in a strong presumption of guilt (BCO 31-2) on the part of TE John Wood in connection with a woman speaking on August 16 and 23, 1998”
    M29GA, p. 70 · original verified
    M29GA, p. 70, with the quote highlighted
  • “However, the SJC concludes that what she said “crossed the line,” as evidenced from the testimony”
    M29GA, p. 71 · original verified
    M29GA, p. 71, with the quote highlighted
  • “there is no clear evidence that TE Wood’s views are outside the bounds of our Standards”
    M29GA, p. 72 · original verified
    M29GA, p. 72, with the quote highlighted
  • “excludes women from ordination; (2) excludes women from preaching (authoritative teaching); (3) permits women to do basically whatever unordained men can do in the church”
    M29GA, p. 72 · original verified
    M29GA, p. 72, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Responds to