PCA History

49th General Assembly · · Birmingham, AL draft

49th General Assembly sends down a ten-percent threshold for original jurisdiction requests

Houston Metro Presbytery’s Overture 8 asked the 49th General Assembly to amend Book of Church Order (BCO) 33-1 and 34-1. As amended by the Overtures Committee, BCO 34-1 would require the General Assembly to assume original jurisdiction over a minister when his presbytery does not indict in a doctrinal case or a case of public scandal and at least ten percent of presbyteries request it. Calvary Presbytery’s Overture 9 asked for a similar change and was answered by reference to Overture 8. The Committee on Constitutional Business advised that the overture conflicted with the right of each court to resolve questions of doctrine. A minority report asked that the overture be referred back to the presbytery. The Assembly adopted the committee’s recommendation (1245-521) and sent the amendment to the presbyteries.

Actors
PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee, Houston Metro Presbytery
About
Calvary Presbytery
Issues
Original jurisdiction and higher-court review of presbyteries

Sources

  • “Amend BCO 33-1 and BCO 34-1 Establishing Percentage Threshold for Original Jurisdiction Requests”
    M49GA, p. 1296 · original verified
  • “Adopted by Houston Metro Presbytery at its stated meeting, January 21, 2022”
    M49GA, p. 1297 · original verified
  • “instances of public scandal and at least ten percent (10%) of Presbyteries request the General Assembly to assume original jurisdiction for a case of process, the General Assembly shall do so”
    M49GA, p. 97 · original verified
  • “In the opinion of the CCB, Overture 8 is in conflict with the principle that every court has the right to resolve questions of doctrine”
    M49GA, p. 420 · original verified
  • “recommending that the Assembly refer Overture 8 back to the Presbytery without prejudice”
    M49GA, p. 85 · original verified
  • “Recommendation 8, to answer O-8 in the affirmative as amended, was adopted 1245-521.”
    M49GA, p. 86 · original verified
  • “That Overture 9 from Calvary Presbytery (“Amend BCO 34-1 to Establish Percentage Threshold for Original Jurisdiction Requests,” p. 1297) be answered with reference to the answer to Overture 8.”
    M49GA, p. 97 · original verified

Submit a correction

Responses

Related

  1. 47th General Assembly declines to define "credible report" in BCO 40-5 draft

    PCA General Assembly, Savannah River Presbytery · Dallas, TX

  2. 53rd General Assembly declines an amendment to BCO 40-5 on citing a lower court draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee, Potomac Presbytery · Louisville, KY

  3. 53rd General Assembly sends down an amendment to BCO 34-1 on the Assembly assuming original jurisdiction draft

    PCA General Assembly, Overtures Committee, Westminster Presbytery · Louisville, KY