PCA History

draft

Standing Judicial Commission denies TE Ryan Speck's complaint against Missouri Presbytery (Case 2020-12)

TE Ryan Speck complained against Missouri Presbytery’s July 2020 decision not to indict TE Greg Johnson; the presbytery denied the complaint 43-6-1, and he carried it to the Standing Judicial Commission. The full commission heard the case on March 25, 2021, and then sent TE Johnson 25 written questions to complete the record. On October 21, 2021, it denied the complaint 16-7. It held that it “was not unreasonable” for the presbytery to judge his explanations satisfactory. RE Jay Neikirk and TE Guy Waters wrote a concurring opinion; RE Samuel J. Duncan and RE Steve Dowling wrote dissenting opinions.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Missouri Presbytery, Greg Johnson, Ryan Speck
Issues
Homosexuality and standards for church office Revoice and the TE Greg Johnson case Judicial cases

Sources

  • “COMPLAINT OF TE RYAN SPECK v. MISSOURI PRESBYTERY DECISION ON COMPLAINT October 21, 2021”
    M49GA, p. 730 · original verified
    M49GA, p. 730, with the quote highlighted
  • “Presbytery approved the Complaint Commission’s proposed denial of TE Speck’s September 17, 2020 Complaint. The vote was 43-6-1”
    M49GA, p. 739 · original verified
    M49GA, p. 739, with the quote highlighted
  • “sending a letter to Presbytery’s Representative with 25 questions for TE Johnson”
    M49GA, p. 731 · original verified
    M49GA, p. 731, with the quote highlighted
  • “It was not unreasonable for Presbytery to judge that TE Johnson’s “explanations” on the four allegations were “satisfactory.””
    M49GA, p. 767 · original verified
    M49GA, p. 767, with the quote highlighted
  • “(16-7-0)”
    M49GA, p. 767 · original verified
    M49GA, p. 767, with the quote highlighted
  • “The Hearing was conducted before the full SJC at its Stated Meeting in Atlanta on March 25, 2021”
    M49GA, p. 730 · original verified
    M49GA, p. 730, with the quote highlighted
  • “This concurring opinion was written by RE Frederick (Jay) Neikirk and TE Guy Prentiss Waters”
    M49GA, p. 791 · original verified
    M49GA, p. 791, with the quote highlighted
  • “This dissenting opinion was written by RE Samuel J. Duncan and joined by RE John Bise, RE Steve Dowling and RE John White”
    M49GA, p. 797 · original verified
    M49GA, p. 797, with the quote highlighted
  • “This opinion was written by RE Steve Dowling”
    M49GA, p. 806 · original verified
    M49GA, p. 806, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Related

  1. Memorial Presbyterian Church votes to leave the PCA draft

    Memorial Presbyterian Church (St. Louis, MO) · St. Louis, MO