PCA History

25th General Assembly · · Colorado Springs, CO draft

25th General Assembly approves the SJC judgment in a complaint over a theonomist's transfer exam in Southern Florida Presbytery

In 1994 Southern Florida Presbytery did not sustain the theology exam of a teaching elder who sought to transfer from Great Lakes Presbytery. The question was his view of Old Testament judicial law under WCF 19-4. The Jupiter church session complained, and in Case 95-5 the Standing Judicial Commission found procedural errors in the presbytery’s handling of the complaint and returned the case for a new hearing. The opinion did not address the substantive issue. A concurring opinion noted that the presbytery had declined to state that theonomic views were the basis of its vote. The 25th General Assembly approved the judgment.

Actors
PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Southern Florida Presbytery
Issues
Theonomy and Christian reconstruction Judicial cases

Sources

  • “That the Judgment of the SJC in the Case 95-5 Jupiter Session vs. Southern Florida Presbytery (Complaint) be approved.”
    M25GA, p. 64 · original verified
    M25GA, p. 64, with the quote highlighted
  • “views of Old Testament judicial law in relation to Westminster Confession of Faith 19-4”
    M25GA, p. 64 · original verified
    M25GA, p. 64, with the quote highlighted
  • “the case is returned to the Presbytery of Southern Florida with instructions for a new hearing”
    M25GA, p. 65 · original verified
    M25GA, p. 65, with the quote highlighted
  • “This opinion does not address the substantive issue regarding membership in the court.”
    M25GA, p. 66 · original verified
    M25GA, p. 66, with the quote highlighted
  • “Presbytery specifically declined to state that theonomic views were the basis of their action”
    M25GA, p. 67 · original verified
    M25GA, p. 67, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Related

  1. 24th General Assembly declines Southern Florida's request for a theonomy study draft

    PCA General Assembly, Southern Florida Presbytery · Fort Lauderdale, FL

  2. 26th General Assembly adopts the SJC majority report in Mt. Carmel Session v. New Jersey Presbytery on creation days draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC), Presbytery of New Jersey · St. Louis, MO

  3. A woman staff member speaks at two Cedar Springs evening services

    Cedar Springs Presbyterian Church · Knoxville, TN