PCA History

draft

Standing Judicial Commission upholds a session that declined elder candidates over theonomy

In Case 91-5 the session of Community Presbyterian Church, Live Oak, Florida, had declined two ruling elder candidates, resolving that “theonomy is out of accord” with WCF 19.4 and divisive. Central Florida Presbytery annulled that clause “based on insufficient clarity,” and the candidates complained to the General Assembly. The full Standing Judicial Commission denied the complaint on March 6, 1992. It held that a court may judge the acceptability of “theological issues that have not been clearly defined by the broader Church,” and it wrote that prior Assemblies “have not spoken clearly on theonomy.” The 20th General Assembly approved the judgment, and seven commissioners recorded negative votes.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Central Florida Presbytery
Issues
Theonomy and Christian reconstruction Judicial cases

Sources

  • “WHEREAS, theonomy is out of accord with Chapter XIX, Paragraph IV of the Westminster Confession of Faith”
    M20GA, p. 197 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 197, with the quote highlighted
  • “the Session of Community Presbyterian Church, Live Oak, Florida, did not approve the examination”
    M20GA, p. 197 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 197, with the quote highlighted
  • “theonomy is a divisive issue in the Presbyterian Church in America”
    M20GA, p. 197 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 197, with the quote highlighted
  • “for the office of ruling elder”
    M20GA, p. 197 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 197, with the quote highlighted
  • “be annulled according to BCO 43-10 based on insufficient clarity”
    M20GA, p. 198 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 198, with the quote highlighted
  • “the Complainants forwarded their complaint to the General Assembly”
    M20GA, p. 198 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 198, with the quote highlighted
  • “the review was held on March 6, 1992”
    M20GA, p. 198 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 198, with the quote highlighted
  • “Judgment of the Case 1. Yes. Therefore, the complaint is denied.”
    M20GA, p. 198 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 198, with the quote highlighted
  • “the right of a church court to determine the acceptability of theological issues that have not been clearly defined by the broader Church”
    M20GA, p. 198 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 198, with the quote highlighted
  • “prior General Assemblies have not spoken clearly on theonomy”
    M20GA, p. 199 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 199, with the quote highlighted
  • “(SJC Docket 91-5) be approved. Adopted”
    M20GA, p. 197 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 197, with the quote highlighted
  • “Requesting their negative votes on Case #91-5 be recorded were”
    M20GA, p. 197 · original verified
    M20GA, p. 197, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction

Responds to

  1. 7th General Assembly adopts a statement on theonomy draft

    PCA General Assembly · Charlotte, NC

  2. 11th General Assembly answers Gulf Coast's questions on theonomy and the judicial law draft

    PCA General Assembly, Gulf Coast Presbytery · Norfolk, VA

Related

  1. 25th General Assembly approves the SJC judgment in a complaint over a theonomist's transfer exam in Southern Florida Presbytery draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Colorado Springs, CO

  2. 19th General Assembly approves the SJC judgment on a Sunday school teacher who held theistic evolution (Case 90-3) draft

    PCA General Assembly, Standing Judicial Commission (SJC) · Birmingham, AL

  3. 20th General Assembly sends down an amendment to let a neighboring presbytery try a minister's case draft

    PCA General Assembly, Presbytery of the Ascension · Roanoke, VA