PCA History

Standing Judicial Commission annuls Northern California Presbytery's statement of six views of the diaconate

In Cases 2009-25/26 (TE David Brown and the session of Grace Presbyterian Church, Pleasanton, against Northern California Presbytery), the Standing Judicial Commission held that the presbytery erred when it adopted an abstract statement of the views on the diaconate that its ministers and sessions could hold. A church court binds only those under its jurisdiction in a proper case, such as the examination of a candidate or a judicial process. The Commission annulled the presbytery’s action. It stated that its judgment gave no opinion on whether the six views were faithful to the Constitution. The vote was 20 concurring, 4 absent. A concurring opinion urged church courts to address specific cases rather than adopt broad statements.

Actors
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
About
Northern California Presbytery
Issues
Women and the diaconate Judicial cases

Sources

  • “Did Northern California Presbytery err when it adopted an abstract statement of what views with respect to the Office of Deacon that Ministers or Sessions may hold and practice”
    M39GA, p. 550 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 550, with the quote highlighted
  • “No Court of this Church is authorized to issue an authoritative decree outside of the proper exercise of its jurisdiction.”
    M39GA, p. 550 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 550, with the quote highlighted
  • “Accordingly, the actions of Presbytery against which the Complaints were made are annulled”
    M39GA, p. 551 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 551, with the quote highlighted
  • “nor by implication, renders Judgment on the fidelity, or lack thereof, of the six views set forth in the actions of Presbytery”
    M39GA, p. 552 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 552, with the quote highlighted
  • “Adopted: 20 concurred, 4 absent”
    M39GA, p. 552 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 552, with the quote highlighted
  • “this Case demonstrates the need for our Courts to directly address specific issues and situations, rather than adopting broad in thesi statements”
    M39GA, p. 552 · original verified
    M39GA, p. 552, with the quote highlighted

Submit a correction