Northern California Presbytery declares six views of the diaconate within the bounds of its ministers and sessions
After the Review of Presbytery Records exceptions on its churches’ diaconal practices, Northern California Presbytery adopted its Procedural Committee’s recommendations. It acknowledged tensions between these practices and the BCO but placed them within the breadth it had historically allowed. It voted on six views one by one, and then declared that ministers and sessions could hold and practice all six:
- Only men are ordained as deacons, and they do the diaconal work of the congregation (30-0).
- Only men are ordained as deacons, and the session appoints men or women to assist them (30-0).
- Only men are ordained as deacons, and the session appoints women as deaconesses to assist them (29-3).
- Only men are ordained as deacons, and the congregation elects women, with the session’s approval, as deaconesses to assist them (26-4).
- Men are ordained as deacons and women are commissioned as deaconesses; the congregation elects both, and they serve as equal partners (21-9).
- Men and women serve as equal partners in diaconal ministry, often called “deacon” or “deaconess,” and no one is ordained (21-9).
The session of Grace Presbyterian Church, Pleasanton, complained against views 3 to 6, and TE David Brown complained against views 5 and 6. On October 9, 2009, the presbytery denied both complaints.
- Actors
- Northern California Presbytery
- Issues
- Women and the diaconate Commissioning versus ordination The title "deaconess"
Sources
-
“At its Stated Meeting on March 7, 2009, Northern California Presbytery adopted a recommendation from its Procedural Committee that six different, written views related to the Diaconate may be held and practiced by Ministers, Sessions, and Member Churches.”
M39GA, p. 548 · original verified
-
“these practices are within the historic breadth allowed by this Presbytery”
M39GA, p. 549 · original verified
-
“Both men and women serve as equal partners in diaconal ministry and are often described as “deacon” or “deaconess” though no one is ordained to this ministry.” (vote 21-9)”
M39GA, p. 550 · original verified
-
“Motion to sustain Complaint of Grace Session (Attachment 9.F.i) failed. Motion to sustain Complaint of TE Brown (Attachment 9.F.ii) failed.”
M39GA, p. 550 · original verified
-
“Only men are ordained as deacons and they conduct the diaconal ministries of the congregation.” (vote 30-0)”
M39GA, p. 549 · original verified
-
“yet Sessions select and appoint others – men and/or women – to assist the deacons in their work.” (vote 30-0)”
M39GA, p. 549 · original verified
-
“appointed by the Session to serve as deaconesses who assist the male deacons.” (vote 29-3)”
M39GA, p. 549 · original verified
-
“yet the congregation elects women, with the approval of the Session, to serve as deaconesses who assist the male deacons.”(vote 26-4)”
M39GA, p. 549 · original verified
-
“women are commissioned as deaconesses without ordination, though both the men and the women are elected by the congregation and serve as equal partners in diaconal ministry.” (vote 21-9)”
M39GA, p. 549 · original verified
Responds to
-
Committee on Review of Presbytery Records finds Northern California Presbytery's response on deaconesses unsatisfactory
Committee on Review of Presbytery Records (RPR) · Dallas, TX
Responses
-
Standing Judicial Commission annuls Northern California Presbytery's statement of six views of the diaconate
Standing Judicial Commission (SJC)
Related
-
byFaith publishes Duncan's "The Case for Our Current Policy on Female Deacons"
byFaith magazine, Ligon Duncan
-
byFaith publishes Keller's "The Case for Commissioning (Not Ordaining) Deaconesses"
byFaith magazine, Timothy Keller
-
Presbyteries ask the 36th General Assembly for a study of women in diaconal ministry
Philadelphia Presbytery, Northern California Presbytery, Western Canada Presbytery, Rocky Mountain Presbytery
-
Overtures Committee minority asks for a study committee
Overtures Committee · Dallas, TX
-
Metro Atlanta Presbytery adopts a resolution on women in diaconal ministry
Metro Atlanta Presbytery
-
Four presbyteries overture the 38th General Assembly to amend BCO 9-7
Evangel Presbytery, Central Carolina Presbytery, Eastern Carolina Presbytery, Westminster Presbytery
-
Rickard asks PCA churches to stop using the title "deaconess"
Thomas Rickard, Presbyterian Polity (pcapolity.com)
-
Six presbyteries overture the 53rd General Assembly on the diaconate, commissioning and titles
Savannah River Presbytery, Catawba Valley Presbytery, Northwest Georgia Presbytery, Mississippi Valley Presbytery, Northern California Presbytery, Eastern Carolina Presbytery