PCA History

29th General Assembly · · Dallas, TX draft

29th General Assembly adopts the consensus recommendations on women in the military

The Ad Interim Study Committee on Women in the Military presented a consensus report, a majority paper, “Man’s Duty to Protect Woman,” and a minority paper, “Recommendations for the Wise Counsel of the Church.” The committee agreed on most points but divided on whether women’s absence from offensive combat was a matter of duty or of wise counsel. The chairman moved to set the recommendations aside and extend the committee, but the 29th General Assembly instead took up the consensus recommendations. It adopted recommendations 1-4 and 8-11, which included a warning to women of the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA) about the dangers of military service, and sent the papers to the presbyteries for study. It recommitted recommendations 5-7 and 12, and a substitute declaring “the biblical duty of men to defend women,” to the committee for the next Assembly.

Actors
PCA General Assembly, Ad Interim Study Committee on Women in the Military (AISCOWIM)
Issues
Women in military combat

Sources

  • “A substitute motion was made to consider the consensus report and recommendations 1-12 on p. 277. The substitute motion was adopted. Recommendations 1-4 and 8-11 were adopted as a unit.”
    M29GA, p. 258 · original verified
    M29GA, p. 258, with the quote highlighted
  • “recommitted the remaining matters (recommendations 5, 6, 7 and 12 and Item 3 on p. 278) back to the committee”
    M29GA, p. 258 · original verified
    M29GA, p. 258, with the quote highlighted
  • “That the women of the PCA be warned of the many difficulties and moral and physical dangers involved in serving in the military in secular America, due to their inherent greater vulnerability.”
    M29GA, p. 277 · original verified
    M29GA, p. 277, with the quote highlighted
  • “the area we could not come to agreement surrounds the question of whether women not participating in offensive combat is a matter of duty, or simply wise counsel”
    M29GA, p. 259 · original verified
    M29GA, p. 259, with the quote highlighted
  • “That this Assembly declare it to be the biblical duty of men to defend women”
    M29GA, p. 278 · original verified
    M29GA, p. 278, with the quote highlighted
  • “Recommendations 1-4 and 8-11 were adopted as a unit.”
    AISCOWIM · original verified
  • “That the women of the PCA be warned of the many difficulties and moral and physical dangers involved in serving in the military in secular America”
    AISCOWIM · original verified
  • “the area we could not come to agreement surrounds the question of whether women not participating in offensive combat is a matter of duty, or simply wise counsel”
    WIM Consensus Report 2001 · original verified

Submit a correction

Responds to

  1. 26th General Assembly forms an ad interim committee on women in the military draft

    PCA General Assembly, Philadelphia Presbytery · St. Louis, MO

Responses

  1. 30th General Assembly declares man's duty to defend woman and condemns women as combatants and their conscription draft

    PCA General Assembly, Ad Interim Study Committee on Women in the Military (AISCOWIM) · Birmingham, AL

Related

  1. 31st General Assembly states that the 30th General Assembly's women-in-the-military action compels no discipline draft

    PCA General Assembly, Potomac Presbytery, Chesapeake Presbytery · Charlotte, NC

  2. 28th General Assembly extends the women-in-the-military committee for another year draft

    PCA General Assembly, Ad Interim Study Committee on Women in the Military (AISCOWIM) · Tampa, FL

  3. 27th General Assembly receives the women-in-the-military report as information and refers it back draft

    PCA General Assembly, Ad Interim Study Committee on Women in the Military (AISCOWIM) · Louisville, KY

  4. 25th General Assembly answers Philadelphia Presbytery's overture against women in combat in the negative draft

    PCA General Assembly, Philadelphia Presbytery · Colorado Springs, CO